Thoughts by Bahadar Ali

May 21, 2010

The Facebook Heat

Filed under: Political — bkhan @ 2:58 am

Back in 1984, General Zia-ul-Haq conducted a referendum to legitimize his rule. The referendum was based on one question: “Do you want to continue the process of Islamization in Pakistan ?”, and the polity was given choices to tick either Yes or No. Now who could say ‘No’ to that kind of a question, but if they said ‘Yes’, which 99 percent ticked, that meant a license for Khadim-e-Islam Gen. Zia-ul-Haq to ‘serve’ the nation for five more years. This was a sham exercise but left a deep scar on the psyche of the nation. Successive times kept on giving similar choices to besieged public. Till this day Pakistanis are struggling between the choices of heaven or hell-fire on similar themes as and when it is deemed fit by the right wing establishment through their surrogates.

Questioning the motive of any similar ‘sacred’ move would promptly disqualify you to be a Muslim. And as with the increasing audacity of the Pakistani religious class nurtured with bigotry, hatred and contempt for fellow human being, any effort for reasoning may not only end up in declaring you as an infidel ( or Jewish friend ) but also in some cases ‘vaijb-ul-qatal’ too. There we are again, back to square one. We are again confronted by the similar situation, when popular social networking web site, the FaceBook, initiated a controversial and condemnable act by one of its members. It sets a stage for all the extremists on the other side of the Islamic divide to come up with a “Drawing Muhammad (PBUH) Competition”. Naturally it wasn’t an effort to patronize the art and the artist, rather intent is openly to ridicule the feelings of 1.2 billion humans. The ostensible backdrop of this effort were the threats hurled at South Park Studios by some extremist Muslim organization and individuals. That too was a similar exercise but they stopped-short of depicting Muhammad ( PBUH ). After those threats sizzling opinions expressed in the global media, which triggered to this uncalled for development at Facebook.

The Islamic world as usual is up in protests. But Pakistan tried to circumvent the situation in a slightly more un-orthodox way, they stepped up and banned the Facebook access for its subscribers over the orders of a provincial High Court. The more recent development is banning of another popular video sharing website YouTube. The Pakistani internet generation is now grappling with a similar situation as were the voters of 1984 Zia’s referendum put in. They cannot openly say that ban will not help and at the same time they cannot reason it. I cannot see, any good coming out of this decision either. It is like burying your head in the sand instead of facing the situation. Don’t we know that internet offers everything, from the online lessons of Holy Quran to the blasphemous material, as deemed under the blasphemy law of Pakistan? It offers every range of information, only user’s imagination is the limit. Why we cannot focus that it is upto the user to watch/read whatever he/she wants. Do we really think that this ban would stop the caricatures to reach their intended audience? Are we going to block internet if the same material starts flowing in the email? This is a futile attempt, only encouraging the perpetrators of such unholy attempts to ridicule us more in the future. Right now whole Islamic world is just offering a theater to watch our spectacles of fury and rage every now and then.

The best approach to deal and to achieve reasonable pause in an effort to dilute the impression that we are intolerant. That instead of logic and reasoning we believe in hostility. But even mention of this approach would develop frowns on the foreheads of many. On one side we claim to be the harbingers of the world’s best civilization, with an educated and a very intelligent past, on the other side we have shun the habit of rational discourse and always utter emotionalism on top of our lungs. At one end we feel pride to be the follower of Mohsin-e-Insaniyat, Hazrat Muahammad ( PBUH ) and in after every prayer we pray to be guided by uswa-i-husna ( Rasool’s footsteps ) and Sunnah. Then why do we forget that Holy Prophet (PBUH) visited the same sick women of Makkah who would throw garbage on him everyday? But I think we have long forgotten these lessons of morality under the noise of Jihad and Petro-Islam which has ruptured our moral and ethical fiber. We have impressioned the harbingers of cruelty and vengeance to be Islamic messiahs while they are just masquerading Islamic trivia to fool us. No this is not the Islam which Rehmatul-lil-Alamin ( PBUH ) has told us. Following this kind of Islam has just made us the laughing stock of the world.

On the current onslaught, emotionalism wouldn’t yield anything. Don’t count on the Jihadis, as their Jihad needs constant financing, no matter where it comes from, in the form of US Dollars, Saudi Riyals or last but not least bank robberies. Intellect and knowledge can be our only weapon. Rational arguments can fetch way more than Kalashnikov bullets. And remember those who can make Facebooks, first they have made weapons, far lethal to protect theirself and in this field too, we are a no match to them. The first thing is to step out of the tunnel mentality and self-aggrandizement. Then face the reality. I know it would be painful and heart breaking to visit those pages, but do visit and make them ashamed of what they are doing. Offer them the alternatives, engage in a dialogue, read them out the Khutba-e-Hujjat-ul-Wida ( The last sermon of holy prophet). Make them know that the personality who they are trying to make fun of, is the greatest personality of the entire human race. Read them aloud Michael Hart’s the ” the 100″ book and tell them why the non-Islamic author picked Hazrat Muhammd(PBUH) as the number one of all the influential human beings among all the living and dead. Quote them the countless world leaders of the past and present who were always inspired by this great personality. Convince them that in their political expediency they are insulting someone who is the most revered one, not by coercion, but by his (PBUH) teachings.

This is the only approach that will result in some solid gains otherwise we would keep on dancing to the tunes of those who trigger the Muslims and then watch the rest of tamasha Muslims make up of our own whereby we go the extent of violent protest that eventually results in the death of few protestors every here and there. I still cannot forget the scene of 1989 protest infront of American Centre in Islamabd, where six people were shot dead by the law enforcers during a protest against Salman Rushdie’s “Satanic Verses”. Enough of it now, ask those who lost their loved-ones. The time of wrestlers and warriors are long gone, right now we are riding the brain wave. The massive and more muscular the brain is, the power goes that way. If you dislike Facebook, don’t visit it, make your own, but please on that don’t let realism slip from your hands.


May 6, 2010

Faisal Shahzad: Just a comment

Filed under: Political — bkhan @ 6:26 am

Extremism is a menace. Usually stems from poverty. But what to say now, when Faisal Shahzad, son of an Air Marshall of Pakistan Air Force. In Pakistani perspective, it is deep rooted, requires commitment from the Pakistani establishment, I emphasize ‘Establishment’. Because it is their ambivalence towards extremism that has spawned this dangerous phenomena to hit all strata of the society. We need to tell them, that extremists cannot win them Kashmir or Afghanistan, rather it is a rust that will eat up the modern day Pakistan.

Blog at